Friday, October 9, 2015

Unanimous Coastal Commission Ruling Breathes Life into #Blackfish Bill AB2140

Anyone who carefully observes or works for SeaWorld (SW) probably realizes that things with the company are sometimes not what they appear to be. 

SW spends tens of millions, annually, to craft perceptions, win politicians, lobby, & also to tarnish critics. As an aside, imagine how far that money could go toward salmon restorationBut at SW, sending bus-loads of hourly employees to a political event in an attempt to influence optics for the CA Coastal Commission is a good return on investment, usually

Update: SeaWorld sues [read on]

On 8 October 2015 SeaWorld bused hundreds of hourly employees & family to the Long Beach Convention Center to create an illusion; to conflate the fact that only 21% of Americans support orca captivity with the fantasy that captivity has strong & widespread public support. It doesn't, and more & more people are figuring out what it truly means to be "pro-cap."

Dr Ingrid Visser with Actress-Model Pamela Anderson. Both spoke at the hearings. Photo by Kim Ventre 

Long Beach was the site of the California Coastal Commission's (CCC) hearing on SeaWorld's proposed Blue World project (BWP). An expansion that is (or was) intended to boost SeaWorld's captive orca population through natural & artificial insemination methods. The hearing was an historic one in terms of attendance & public engagement. 

SeaWorld's self-titled "mob buses" brought in plenty of support, but employees may have been on the clock because those workers evaporated like California's water supply.  

#EmptyThe.... Chairs! -- Did SeaWorld want to avoid overtime to workers on the clock? 

Maybe SW was being frugal and didn't want to pay its people overtime [we were told they were on the clock] because when the buses departed back to SW headquarters the "mob" was gone.  And despite Commissioner Cox's efforts to cement SeaWorld's legacy at San Diego, the few SeaWorld employees remaining didn't like what they heard. 

2 bad days @ work. You'd think a risky job, like pro football player, would come with union protection. Not @SeaWorld

In a unanimous vote the CCC granted SeaWorld the right to build Blue World, but with a major condition: No more orca breeding 

As reported by The Times of San Diego: 

By a 12-0 vote, the California Coastal Commission blessed the Blue World Project. The decision came at an overflow meeting in the Long Beach Convention Center that saw dozens of passionate speeches, including one by animal-rights activist Pamela Anderson. 
But Commissioner Dayna Bochco of San Francisco... proposed an amendment to prohibit any breeding of orcas, their artificial insemination or their trade or transfer among other parks. Another condition is a cap of 15 whales at the San Diego attraction, which now houses 11. 
Bochco’s amendment to Condition 1 passed 11-1, with only Greg Cox — a San Diego County supervisor — dissenting.

The "no breeding" condition didn't sit well with SeaWorld's leadership. The statement, below, by CEO Joel Manby is ironic considering SeaWorld has traditionally argued that it's animals have no rights. Are Manby's days numbered? 

Treating the whales as property allows for SW to imprison them without considering how the whales feel about that. It also allows the corporation to ship them overseas to places like Loro Parque. There's more... 

Ironic that the "warden" is claiming that captive orcas  have rights 

Blue World is Also a Political Maneuver to Sink AB-2140

On the surface, San Diego makes the least sense for BWP. SeaWorld doesn't own the land; the city does. Construction costs are higher in California v Texas or Orlando. Wouldn't a company with huge debt, like SeaWorld, seek the best deal on such an expensive project? 

The corporate HQ's & highest attended park is Orlando, not San Diego. SW in FL and SW in TX don't need to ask commissioners for approval. The politics, on the surface, favor Orlando & San Antonio as cheaper & easier sites for a 50 ft deep concrete orca tank. So why spend millions to lobby approval for and to construct BWP at Mission Bay, the most expensive site?

Because BWP is about political clout, crushing upcoming legislation, and thus cementing SeaWorld's grasp on captivity inside the USA. California is the world's 8th largest economy, behind #7, Brazil.

Had BWP moved forward, un-amended, San Diego was expected to become the "West Coast puppy mill for killer whales." This would be complimented nicely by SeaWorld's proposed "Worlds largest fish farm" just a few miles from the San Diego park. Granted, the farm is touted to "grow" yellow-fin tuna, but SeaWorld famously does not recognize dietary or cultural differences between ecotypes, and killer whales are known to eat tuna. Look here. Or here

Site of SeaWorld's proposed fish farm, the world's largest;  Just a few miles off the San Diego Coast. 

Additionally, SeaWorld has [already] announced expansion plans to shareholders & wants to increase its killer whale assets for shipments abroad, including to China and Dubai. Thanks to Commissioner Bocho, the "puppy mill" idea has been thwarted, for now. But that's not the end of the story.  

Connecting Blue World (BWP) with AB-2140 

SeaWorld understood that if the Commission green-lighted BWP, politicians would be inclined to vote down Richard Bloom's upcoming Blackfish Bill AB-2140, aka The Orca Welfare & Safety Act. That bill is sponsored by three former SeaWorld killer whale trainers, Carol Ray, John Hargrove and Samantha Berg, and was tabled last year using political maneuvering. SeaWorld was fond of portraying AB-2140 as "dead." Listen to Carol discuss Bloom's proposed legislation, here.

Because BWP is a multi-year, one-hun
dred million dollar project, it would impact dozens or hundreds of potential jobs & businesses around California, and the politicians that represent them. BWP would require construction crews, crane operators, engineers, water quality experts, environmental scientists, architects, employment contracts, and more. It is strongly supported by the San Diego business community & politicians on both sides of the aisle. 

This is because politicians put jobs & economic growth ahead of orca welfare. And SeaWorld knows this. But... 


Not So Fast 

Now, with a unanimous vote by a state agency which is on the record and opposed to captive orca breeding, Richard Bloom's AB-2140 has new life and legs.  Like the recent lunar eclipse, AB-2140 has moved into alignment with the BWP, both would make it illegal for SeaWorld to breed captive killer whales in California. 

And this was immediately apparent to Assemblymember Richard Bloom who went onto social media to express that he's moving forward, now. 

Regarding the BWP in California, its future is uncertain. Some predict that SeaWorld will file a lawsuit vs the CCC. Others predict it will abandon the idea. 

Behind closed doors, here is the conversation, from SeaWorld's perspective:

1) The CCC did not have legal authority to make the decision that it did! We need to sue them -- confirmed. SW will sue. 

2) Do we want 2-3 more years of mostly negative press associated with litigation?

3) Is our tank expansion worth taking to a friendlier site, such as Orlando?

4) Is now the time to accelerate our plans for expansion into China or Dubai where laws make it easier for us to do our business?

SeaWorld's attorney, David Watson, angrily told the panel “the state of California does not have jurisdiction to regulate the management & care of marine mammal collections”

Thanks to Haze Sommer -- Watch Recorded Streams of The Hearings  HERE: 

The Last World by Commissioner Bocho

When you've lost Willie, you've lost America 

In regard to SeaWorld's next move, only time will tell. But one thing's for sure: The captivity industry is struggling in part due to the work of good souls, facts & the Blackfish Effect.

-------------------  From Dodo, Below   ----------------------


  1. I also suspect that SeaWorld will file a suit against CCC and if they do not file a suit or lose the suit then they will so that they can not build a expanded tank because it takes away their orca's ability to have calf's.

    What I found interesting is how Keiko was brought up in hearing and Keiko has nothing to do with the tank expansion. The one thing that I hate about SeaWorld is how they say that kids learn education through the shows. I know for a fact that I have never been to SeaWorld and I learned about wild animals through movies, documentaries and animal planet. I use to watch Big Cat Diary and learned quite a bit as a child when this show was still around.

  2. Megan, they probably WILL argue that, lol. Ironically, one impediment (there were many) to natural breeding was thought to be the lack of space in the pools. Captive orcas are not a representation of wild orcas in any way. If SeaWorld had (greatly) expanded the habitats ten years ago or more and developed a real natural breeding program, they might have a little more ability to counter all of the criticism. They didn't.

  3. A puppy mill was unlikely the main course to expand. Selling orcas would have been part of a larger business. I don't think they ever planned to build BWP. Just a desperate move to buy time. Will be interesting to see how they close the three SWs in a way they can still operate the other 8 parks.

  4. I've stated this many times on Twitter and FB following the CCC's hopes that SW will SEE IT, and think, 'hmm...'.

    Wouldn't it make more sense for them, because they're the leading marine park name, to close their SD site, retire its whales, build a seaside SUPER theme park to rival all other parks with that $100m, their customer base would return, the anti-cap people would praise the decision and very likely support them in this decision, their investors/stockholders would return (giving them additional money to build this park) their annual passholders would be offered their first year's pass at half price, not to mention many more percs that would likely fall into place...and EVERYONE'S HAPPY!!! What are they waiting for????

    1. (Well, aside of the humiliation that would come with admitting defeat - but it's not really defeat, if what they're doing is making the MAJORITY of people out there, happy with the decision! They're going to tank eventually, probably sooner rather than later, with the way things are going; so why not step into this plan, and use the opportunity to SAVE SW's reputation, by doing the right thing?)

  5. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  6. Seaworld isn't going anywhere. Seaworld doesn't need San Diego, San Diego needs Seaworld. If San Diego wants to shoot itself in the foot then I say let them. Close the park and do the planned overseas expansions. Send the killer whales to Dubai and China.


  7. Are you looking for funds for your projects? We are a private lending firm that specialized in project funding and general financial service thus we offer worldwide loans at affordable interest rates. we do offer all types of loans from Personal loans, debt consolidation loans, business loans, real estate loans, Energy, Oil and Gas, Pharmaceuticals, Biotechnology, Emerging markets, Aviation, High-technology, communications, software, etc. Whereas our goal is to assist you with your immediate financial needs, as well as to develop a long term business relationship with you and your company. We are here to provide the best financial solution to help grow your business to its full potential. We pride ourselves in proven results by delivering a custom-tailored business solution to each of our clients. Feel free to contact us. Our rates are unbeatable and friendly, and our processes are very swift and time-sensitive! *We are open to all, if interested, kindly reply to us via email: Terms and Conditions apply